ZACHARY
TAYLOR . 1849-1850
Northerners and southerners disputed whether territories
wrested from Mexico should be opened to slavery, and
some southerners threatened secession. Zachary Taylor
was prepared to hold the Union together by armed force
rather than by compromise.
Born in
Barboursville, Virginia on November 24, 1784, he was
raised on a Kentucky plantation. A career officer in
the army, he made his home in Baton Rouge, Louisiana,
and owned a plantation in Mississippi. But Taylor did
not defend slavery or southern sectionalism. 40 years
in the army made him a firm nationalist. He had policed
frontiers against Indians and had won major victories
in the Mexican War.
"Old Rough
and Ready's" homespun ways were political assets. His
long military record would appeal to northerners; his
ownership of 100 slaves would lure southern votes. He
had not committed himself on troublesome issues. The
Whigs nominated him to run against the Democratic candidate,
Lewis Cass, who favored letting the residents of territories
decide for themselves whether they wanted slavery. In
protest against Taylor and Cass, northerners who opposed
extension of slavery into territories formed a Free
Soil Party and nominated Martin Van Buren. In a close
election, the Free Soilers pulled enough votes away
from Cass to elect Taylor to the presidency.
Traditionally,
people could decide whether they wanted slavery when
they drew up new state constitutions. Therefore, to
end the dispute over slavery in new areas, President
Taylor urged New Mexico and California to draft constitutions
and apply for statehood, bypassing the territorial stage.
Southerners were furious, since neither state constitution
was likely to permit slavery; Members of Congress were
dismayed, since they felt the president was usurping
their policy-making prerogatives. In addition, Taylor's
solution ignored several acute side issues: the northern
dislike of the slave market operating in the District
of Columbia; and the southern demands for a more stringent
fugitive slave law.
In early
1850 Taylor held a conference with southern leaders
who threatened secession. He told them that those "taken
in rebellion against the Union, he would hang...with
less reluctance than he had hanged deserters and spies
in Mexico." He never wavered.
Then events
took an unexpected turn. After participating in July
4 ceremonies at the Washington Monument, Taylor fell
ill. Within five days he was dead. After his death,
the forces of compromise triumphed, but the war Taylor
had been willing to face came 11 years later. In it,
his only son Richard served as a general in the Confederate
Army.
MILLARD
FILLMORE . 1850-1853
In his rise from a log cabin to the White House, Millard
Fillmore proved that through methodical industry and
some competence an uninspiring man could make the American
dream come true.
Born in
Summerhill, New York on January 7,1800, Fillmore worked
on his father's farm. In 1823 he was admitted to the
bar; seven years later he moved his law practice to
Buffalo. Fillmore held state office and for eight years
was a member of the House of Representatives. In 1848,
while comptroller of New York, he was elected vice president.
He presided
over the Senate during the months of debates over the
Compromise of 1850. A few days before President Taylor's
death, Fillmore intimated that if there should be a
tie vote the bill, he would vote in favor of it. Thus
his accession to the presidency in July 1850 brought
an abrupt political shift in the administration. Taylor's
cabinet resigned and President Fillmore appointed Daniel
Webster as secretary of state, thus proclaiming his
alliance with the moderate Whigs who favored the Compromise.
A bill to
admit California aroused all the violent arguments over
the extension of slavery. At this critical juncture,
President Fillmore announced in favor of the Compromise.
On August 6, 1850, he sent a message to Congress recommending
that Texas be paid to abandon her claims to part of
New Mexico. This helped influence many northern Whigs
in Congress away from their insistence upon the Wilmot
Proviso - the stipulation that all land gained by the
Mexican War must be closed to slavery.
Stephen
A Douglas of Illinois presented five separate bills
to the Senate: 1) Admit California as a free state.
2) Settle the Texas boundary and compensate her. 3)
Grant territorial status to New Mexico. 4) Place federal
officers at the disposal of slaveholders seeking fugitives.
5) Abolish the slave trade in the District of Columbia.
Each measure
obtained a majority, and by September 20, President
Fillmore had signed them into law. The more militant
northern Whigs remained irreconcilable, refusing to
forgive Fillmore for having signed the Fugitive Slave
Act. They helped deprive him of the presidential nomination
in 1852.
As the Whig
Party disintegrated in the 1850's, Fillmore refused
to join the Republican Party; but, instead, in 1856
accepted the nomination for president of the Know Nothing,
or American, Party. Throughout the Civil War he opposed
President Lincoln and during Reconstruction supported
President Johnson. He died in 1874.
FRANKLIN
PIERCE . 1853-1857
Franklin Pierce became president at a time of apparent
tranquillity. The United States, by virtue of the Compromise
of 1850, seemed to have weathered its sectional storm.
Pierce, a New Englander, hoped to prevent still another
outbreak of that storm. But his policies, far from preserving
calm, hastened the disruption of the Union.
Born in
Hillsborough, New Hampshire, on November 23, 1804, Pierce
attended Bowdoin College. He studied law, then entered
politics. He became speaker of the New Hampshire legislature.
In the 1830s he went to Washington, first as a representative,
then as a senator. Pierce was proposed for the 1852
presidential nomination. At the Democratic Convention,
the delegates agreed upon a platform pledging support
of the Compromise of 1850 and hostility to any efforts
to agitate the slavery question. They eliminated all
the well-known candidates before nominating Pierce,
a true "dark horse." He won with a narrow margin of
popular votes. But with the sudden death of his only
son, Pierce found little cause for celebration.
In his inaugural
he proclaimed an era of peace and prosperity at home,
and vigor in relations with other nations. Pierce had
only to make gestures toward expansionism to excite
the wrath of northerners, who accused him of acting
as a cat's-paw of southerners eager to extend slavery
into other areas. Therefore he aroused apprehension
when he pressured Great Britain to relinquish its special
interests along part of the Central American coast,
and even more when he tried to persuade Spain to sell
Cuba.
But the
most violent renewal of the storm stemmed from the Kansas-Nebraska
Act, which repealed the Missouri Compromise and reopened
the question of slavery in the West. This measure, the
handiwork of Senator Stephen A. Douglas, grew in part
out of his desire to promote a railroad from Chicago
to California through Nebraska. Already, land that now
compromises southern Arizona and New Mexico had been
purchased for a southern transcontinental route. The
proposal, to organize western territories through which
a railroad might run, caused extreme trouble. Douglas
provided in his bills that the residents of the new
territories could decide the slavery question for themselves.
The result was a rush into Kansas, as southerners and
northerners vied for control of the territory. Shooting
broke out, and "bleeding Kansas" became a prelude to
the Civil War.
By the end
of his administration, Pierce could claim "a peaceful
condition of things in Kansas." But, to his disappointment,
the Democrats refused to renominate him, turning to
the less controversial Buchanan. Pierce returned to
New Hampshire, leaving his successor to face the rising
fury of the sectional whirlwind. He died in 1869.
JAMES
BUCHANAN . 1857-1861
Tall, stately, stiffly formal in the high stock he wore
around his jowls, James Buchanan was the only president
who never married. Born in Cove Gap, Pennsylvania, on
April 23,1791, Buchanan, a graduate of Dickinson College,
was learned in the law. After being elected five times
to the House of Representatives, he served for a decade
in the Senate. He became Polk's secretary of state and
Pierce's minister to Great Britain. Service abroad helped
to bring Buchanan the Democratic nomination in 1856
because it had exempted him from involvement in bitter
domestic controversies.
As president-elect,
he thought the crisis would disappear if he maintained
a sectional balance in his appointments and could persuade
the people to accept constitutional law as the Supreme
Court interpreted it. The Court was considering the
legality of restricting slavery in the territories,
and two justices hinted to Buchanan what the decision
would be. Thus, in his inaugural the president referred
to the territorial question as " a matter of but little
practical importance" since the Court was about to settle
it "speedily and finally."
Two days
later the Court delivered the Dred Scott decision, asserting
that Congress had no constitutional power to deprive
persons of their property rights in slaves in the territories.
Southerners were delighted, but the decision created
a furor in the North.
When Republicans
won a plurality in the House in 1858, every significant
bill they passed fell before southern votes in the Senate
or a presidential veto. The government reached a stalemate.
Sectional strife rose to such a pitch in 1860 that the
Democratic Party split into northern and southern wings,
each nominating its own candidate for the presidency.
When the Republicans nominated Abraham Lincoln, it was
a foregone conclusion that he would be elected even
though his name appeared on no southern ballot. Rather
than accept a Republican administration, the southern
"fire-eaters" advocated secession. President Buchanan,
dismayed and hesitant, denied the legal right of states
to secede but held that the Federal Government legally
could not prevent them. He hoped for compromise, but
secessionist leaders did not want compromise.
Then Buchanan
took a more militant tack. As several cabinet members
resigned, he appointed northerners, and sent the Star
of the West to carry reinforcements to Fort Sumter.
On January 9, 1861, the vessel was fired upon and driven
away.
Buchanan
reverted to a policy of inactivity that continued until
he left office. In March1861 he retired to his Pennsylvania
home Wheatland - where he died seven years later - leaving
his successor to resolve the frightful issue facing
the nation.